block vs crit

[TIMPSON]

If imagine 1 guy got 100% block another 100% crit, when crit guy hit block guy what will hapen? Block or crit will apear?

[TIMPSON]

Nobody knows?

[Bj_Knows]

Nobody knows?

I do not know Tsuruchi. But they claim to know the answer:

Edit: very last Post.

https://www.venan.com/boh_forum/viewtopic.php?p=10602#p10602

[CodeMonkey]

If imagine 1 guy got 100% block another 100% crit, when crit guy hit block guy what will hapen? Block or crit will apear?

Block will win. We first determine the outcome of the attack (hit, dodge, block), then if you are eligible to crit we roll for that. Blocks can't be crits, so the block 'wins' in this case since it is evaluated first.

[Possessed_Mithrid]

Block will win. We first determine the outcome of the attack (hit, dodge, block), then if you are eligible to crit we roll for that. Blocks can't be crits, so the block 'wins' in this case since it is evaluated first.

This is a crucial piece of information...BJ I trust you will archive this somewhere in the guides.

[Monkey006]

Out of curiosity, how do you roll for dodge/block? For instance, let's say dodge and block chances are 15% (for simplicity sake). Do you roll them separate at 15% apiece? Or a cumulative roll of 30% and then a secondary roll to determine block/dodge? It seems to be the latter from my experience, which is huge in PVP

[MysticRPG]

If imagine 1 guy got 100% block another 100% crit, when crit guy hit block guy what will hapen? Block or crit will apear?

Block will win. We first determine the outcome of the attack (hit, dodge, block), then if you are eligible to crit we roll for that. Blocks can't be crits, so the block 'wins' in this case since it is evaluated first.

Is this still the case? If an attack is blocked then it can not be a crit? So an attack of 1000 damage is blocked by a large shield then only 500 damage will get through and no crit chance no matter what the attackers crit is?

[GingerWithAFro]

Out of curiosity, how do you roll for dodge/block? For instance, let's say dodge and block chances are 15% (for simplicity sake). Do you roll them separate at 15% apiece? Or a cumulative roll of 30% and then a secondary roll to determine block/dodge? It seems to be the latter from my experience, which is huge in PVP

If they did this the cumulative roll to be fair would be more like 17.25 cause it wouldn't add 15% it would add 15% of your chance (15%). But I can't guarantee they are being completely fair.

[MysticRPG]

If imagine 1 guy got 100% block another 100% crit, when crit guy hit block guy what will hapen? Block or crit will apear?

Block will win. We first determine the outcome of the attack (hit, dodge, block), then if you are eligible to crit we roll for that. Blocks can't be crits, so the block 'wins' in this case since it is evaluated first.

Is this still the case? If an attack is blocked then it can not be a crit? So an attack of 1000 damage is blocked by a large shield then only 500 damage will get through and no crit chance no matter what the attackers crit is?

I just wanted to bump this request for clarification.
Thanks

[EricM]

I'm also a little confused about this.

Two scenarios...

1) PVE in LoB p4. My SW drinks a crit potion. My crit rate is effectively 101% with piercing strike. However, left boss still blocks occasionally. Does this mean block supercedes crit?

2) PVP. My SW, when defending, should theoretically be at 100% block+dodge. Yet, I have still been hit by crits while defending. So in that case, does crit supercede dodge/block?